In the case of Josephus we possess extensive works proceeding from the ripe experience of a stirring political and intellectual life, in sum a very considerable pile of literature, and that from the generation that marks the dividing point in Judaism’s history.

---

JEWISH SOURCES
Two Phases of History and Literature

---

This archive is a holding space for the entire history of the Hebrew language and the Jewish people.   It isn’t really ready for publication, but the project needs to be put off until next year.

The history of the Jews being presented here in found its two natural phases: first from the time of Moses to the end of the Second Jewish Commonwealth in AD70, and then from the Days of the Messiah up to the modern day.

It has been suggested that Hebrew is the original language of man, and that the nations were cast out of its usage at Babel.  Whether or not this is so, there is ample evidence of the currency of the Hebrew Language during a span of at least three thousand years.  Much of that tongue’s literature, and the history which surrounds it, will be archived here starting in the coming weeks.

• The Temple and Early Christian Identity
• Antisemitism Study Archive – “There are two sides to the coin of ancient Israel’s history.  The touch of God upon the pinnacle of Sinai must be balanced against the touch of God upon the pinnacle of the temple in A.D.70.   The first was felt at the formation of the nation, the latter at its dissolution.   It is important to realize that Preterists don’t see the fall of Jerusalem in AD70 as punishment from God for the murder of Christ, as much as the natural consequence of having rejected him.  in other words, the Jewish nation destroyed itself by rejecting Jesus as Israel.”

---

PHASE ONE LITERATURE
(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

• Torah – Or “TaNaKh”, an acronym denoting these three sections:
  • Torah (Teaching)
  • Nevi’im (Prophets) –  Former (Deuteronomic Code); Latter (Literary)
  • Ketuvim (Writings) Canonical Collection From Post-Prophetic Age
  • Apocrypha
  • Dead Sea Scrolls – Collection of Materials Found in Judean Desert
  • Jewish Apocalyptic – “Turn of Era” Lit. Exploring Eschatological Salvation
    • Pseudepigrapha

PHASE TWO

• Histories of Josephus (First major writings of Phase Two)
• Talmud and Historians (Comment and expansion upon Mishnah)
  • Mishnah (1st-2nd century rabbinic book of laws/values)
  • Gamara (Agadah: tales and morals ; Halacha: code of law)
    • 0200-600: Babylonian (“Bavli”)
    • 0200-500: Palestinian (“Yerushalmi”)
• Midrash (Exegetical interpretation of the Torah)
  • 0010-0500: Halakhah (Interpreting law and religious practice)
    • 0010-0220: Tannaitic Period
    • 0220-0500: Amoraic Period
  • 0200-1000: Aggadah – Biblical Narrative ; Ethics, Theology, Homily
• Targums (Translations of the Bible into Jewish Aramaic)
• Liturgical Texts (Routine prayers)
• Reference Works (Encyclopedias, Dictionaries, Concordances)

---

FROM PDF BIBLIOGRAPHY:

JEWISH QUARTERLY REVIEW:  JQR published first in London and subsequently in Philadelphia. The Jewish Quarterly Review was established in 1889 by I. Abrahams and C.G. Montefiore, who acted as editors. Modeled on the scholarly journals published in Europe, the JQR attracted articles from the great savants of the day, and much original scholarship (e.g., Schechter’s genizah discoveries) first appeared in its pages. But the JQR differed by giving space to more ephemeral topics, as well as including theological controversies. At the beginning of volume 20, the editors announced their intention to discontinue the “quarterly,” stating that their hope that it “might be the medium for a living theology” had been disappointed, and that Abrahams was finding his editorial duties too onerous.  Cyrus Adler, president of the newly established Dropsie College in Philadelphia, offered to take over the JQR, and a new series, published by Dropsie College and edited by Cyrus Adler and Solomon Schechter, began in July 1910.

TD: Listed below are complete volumes from 1889 to 1923.  Volume 8 of Abrahams-Montefiore was unavailable online (apparently).  That volume’s articles were therefore collated and then reconstructed into a single volume in order to produce a complete set.  As newer volumes of Adler-Schechter come online they will be added to the archive.  All documents are pdf files.

• 1889-1908: Abrahams-Montefiore, Jewish Quarterly Review – INDEX | V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7 | V8 | V9 | V10 | V11 | V12 | V13 | V14 | V15 | V16 | V17 | V18 | V19 | V20
  • 1898: I. Abrahams, A Hitherto Unknown Messianic Movement Among the Jews
  • 1899: I. Abrahams, Psudeo-Josephus, Joseph Ben-Gorion
  • 1899: James Montgomery, The Religion of Flavius Josephus
  • 1899: I. Abrahams,The Spiritual Possibilities of Judaism Today
  • 1890: I. Abrahams, The Jewish Sibylline Oracles
  • 1891: I. Abrahams, The Sabbath Light
  • 1893: I. Abrahams, The Emperor Julian and the Jews
  • 1894: I. Abrahams, Brune’s ‘Flavius Josephus’
  • 1895: I. Abrahams, The Referenes to the ‘King’ in the Psalter
  • 1896: K. Kohler, The Essenes and the Apocalyptic Literature
  • 1896: Nina Davis, A Dirge for the Ninth of Ab
  • 1896: I. Abrahams, Priests and Worship in the Last Decade of the Temple at Jerusalem
  • 1897: I. Abrahams, The Messiah Ideal
• 1910-1923: Adler-Schechter, Jewish Quarterly Review – V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7 | V8 | V9 | V10 | V11 | V12

• 1737: John Home, The Scripture History of the Jews, and Their Republick
• 1786: John Bolton, History of Jerusalem and the Temple
• 1822: MacKnight, History of the World to AD70
• 1825: Thomas Brown, History of the Destruction of the City and Temple of Jerusalem
• 1825: Dublin, History of the Siege and Destruction of Jerusalem | Two
• 1829: John Jahn, History of the Hebrew Commonwealth
• 1831: Esther Copely, Sacred History to the Destruction of Jerusalem
• 1832: London, History of the Jews for All Ages
• 1854: William Hale, History of the Jews to AD70
• 1861: Henry White, Sacred History to the Destruction of Jerusalem in AD70
• 1864: Frederich Madden, The History of Jewish Coinage
• 1873: William Gowan Todd, Sacred History From Creation to AD70
• 1878: H.H. Milman, History of the Jews to AD70
• 1880: Isaac Wise, History of the Second Hebrew Commonwealth
• 1883: Heinrich Ewald, The History of Israel, V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7 | V8
• 1889-1908: Abrahams-Montefiore, Jewish Quarterly Review – INDEX | V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7 | V8 | V9 | V10 | V11 | V12 | V13 | V14 | V15 | V16 | V17 | V18 | V19 | V20
  • 1898: I. Abrahams, A Hitherto Unknown Messianic Movement Among the Jews
  • 1899: I. Abrahams, Psudeo-Josephus, Joseph Ben-Gorion
  • 1899: James Montgomery, The Religion of Flavius Josephus
  • 1899: I. Abrahams,The Spiritual Possibilities of Judaism Today
  • 1890: I. Abrahams, The Jewish Sibylline Oracles
  • 1891: I. Abrahams, The Sabbath Light
  • 1893: I. Abrahams, The Emperor Julian and the Jews
  • 1894: I. Abrahams, Brune’s ‘Flavius Josephus’
  • 1895: I. Abrahams, The Referenes to the ‘King’ in the Psalter
  • 1896: K. Kohler, The Essenes and the Apocalyptic Literature
  • 1896: Nina Davis, A Dirge for the Ninth of Ab
  • 1896: I. Abrahams, Priests and Worship in the Last Decade of the Temple at Jerusalem
  • 1897: I. Abrahams, The Messiah Ideal
• 1890: Alfred Edersheim, The Bible History of the Old Testament, V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7
• 1890-96: Emil Schurer, History of the Jewish People in the Time of Jesus Christ, D1-V1 | D1-V2 | D2-V1 | D2-V2 | D2-V3 | Index
• 1904: W. Shaw Caldecott, The Tabernacle – It’s History and Structure
• 1910-1923: Adler-Schechter, Jewish Quarterly Review – V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7 | V8 | V9 | V10 | V11 | V12
• 1912: The Jewish Encyclopedia – V1 | V2 | V3 | V4 | V5 | V6 | V7 | V8 | V9

SEE ALSO:
(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

• Antisemitism Study Archive
• The Days of the Messiah
• John Thomas, The Last Days of Judah’s Commonwealth
• Two phase literature below article list

---

William Whiston: Footnotes on Fulfilled Prophecy in Josephus, History of the Destruction of Jerusalem (1737)

This translation of Josephus’s account of the Jewish rebellion against Rome in the first century may have served as inspiration for the author of the Declaration of Independence. It survives from Thomas Jefferson’s personal library.

William Warburton: Julian, or, A discourse concerning the earthquake and fiery eruption (1750)

This, therefore, being on of the most important eras in the economy of grace, and the most awful revolution in all God’s religious dispensations

Walter Chamberlain: The National Restoration and Conversion of the Twelve Tribes of Israel (1854)

there are, probably, many learned Hebrews who will be astonished to hear that he who propounded them has maintained that all prophecy, extending to Israel as a nation, has already been fulfilled.

Vern Mason: Israel Received All of the Land (2002)

It has been said by some very Godly old time bible scholars that all of God’s promises are conditional.  The land promises did not specifically say that Israel would occupy even though they disobeyed — only that it would be given to them.

Triumphal Arch In Jerusalem? (2007)

The new and extremely rare inscription is incised onto a huge limestone slab  which contains five broken lines of a text written in Latin. The text reads as follows:

Transition Text Theory Study Archive

Did Jesus divide His Olivet Discourses between two subjects and separate their fulfillment by thousands of years?  If so, how or when?

Titus Flavius Vespasianus Study Archive

God co-operates with us. — Their miseries, by your valor and God’s assistance, are multiplied. Their factions, famine, siege, and the falling of their walls without a battery, do they not manifest that God is angry with them, and assists us? – Titus

Tisha B’Av Study Archive

On the “ninth of Ab” it was decreed concerning our fathers, that they should not enter into the land (of Canaan), the first and second temple were destroyed,  Tisha B’av may have been our 9/11, but out of this painful crucible, we will eventually emerge stronger and more robust than ever before

Thomas Williamson: Dispensationalism and Racism (2003)

Any theological teaching that gives Jews a place of privilege over Palestinians or Gentiles in general, or that places any added burdens and restrictions upon the Jews because of their ethnicity, is a relic of an unenlightened past

Thomas Gorey: Josephus and the Rebels’ Cry of ”The Son Comes!” in A.D. 70 (2003)

The implication is that Josephus reported the watchmen’s cry based on their mispronunciation of “ha-eben” (“the stone”) as “habben” (“the son”).

The Return of Jesus in the Bible, the Quran and Hadith

Then it hit me. The Germans and Japanese created this book (The Protocols of the Elders of Zion), as deliberately written lies against the Jewish and American peoples to scapegoat and foster a nationalistic “hate” to the point of creating a world war.

The Psalms of Solomon (0050)

Other Jewish intertestimentary writings further show hatred for Rome, “the sinner Who broke down the strong walls [of Jerusalem] with a battering ram…” (Psalms of Solomon 2: 1)

The Passion According to Isaiah (2000)

One hundred Jews on the streets of Tel Aviv were asked, “Who do you think the 53rd chapter of Isaiah describes?” Most were unfamiliar with the passage and were asked to read it before answering. After doing so, many conceded that they did not know to whom it referred.

The Jerusalem Declaration on Christian Zionism (2013)

It is with concern that we note the negative opinions about Christian Zionism voiced by certain church clerics in Jerusalem in a recent statement entitled, “The Jerusalem Declaration on Christian Zionism” (view entire statement below). Using inflammatory language they have expressed views that are far from the truth.

The Dead Sea Scrolls: A message for Jews and Christians (2010)

Although Mr Vermes does not spell this out in detail, there is also some intriguing news for Christians: certain “Old Testament” passages which they hold dear—but which are mysteriously absent in the Masoretic version—do feature in the scrolls. They don’t seem to have been late Christian inventions.

The Days of the Messiah Study Archive

What then are we to understand by the LATTER or LAST TIMES, so often mentioned in the Scriptures? Not the end of the world, but the end of the Jewish state; the times of Messiah, the fulness of time, or end of the dispensations by revelation from heaven. – Gregory Sharpe

 

The Book of Jubilees (135 B.C.)

they shall name the great name, but not in truth and not in righteousness, and they shall defile the holy of holies with their uncleanness and the corruption of their pollution. And a great punishment shall befall the deeds of this generation

The Assumption of Moses (0020)

Since the Temple appears to be still standing, whereas Herod is dead and his sons appear to be ruling, the date must fall in the first third of the first century C.E.

The Ascension of Isaiah (0075)

And after it has come to its consummation, Beliar, the great prince, the king of this world who has ruled it since it came into being, shall descend; he will come down from his firmament in the form of a man, a lawless king, a slayer of his mother

The Apocalypse of Enoch (165 B.C.)

And in it a man shall ascend; And at its close the house of dominion shall be burnt with fire, And the whole race of the chosen root shall be dispersed. (Apocalypse of Weeks)

Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs (109 B.C.)

Therefore the temple which the Lord shall choose shall be desolate in uncleanness, and ye shall be captives throughout all nations, and ye shall be an abomination among them, and ye shall receive reproach and everlasting shame from the righteous judgment of God; and all who see you shall flee from you.

Taylor-Schechter Genizah Collection

The heretical is present in the writings of various dissident Jewish sects, compositions probably banished to the Genizah whenever they appeared in Old Cairo.

Targums Study Archive

The word “targum” refers to translations of the Bible into Jewish Aramaic. In the post-exilic period, Aramaic began to be widely spoken in the Jewish community alongside the native language, Hebrew. Eventually Aramaic replaced Hebrew for most purposes, and the Bible itself required translation into the more widely familiar vernacular language.

Talmud and Historians Study Archive

You look at something like the story in the Talmud about the destruction of Jerusalem, about Kamtso and Bar Kamtso. Ultimately it turned on a piece of khnoykishkayt [hypocritical sanctimoniousness]

Stone Tablet Celebrating Masada’s Destroyer discovered (2007)

Now the Israeli newspaper Haaretz reports the discovery and the first imaging of an ancient Roman stone tablet honoring Flavius Silva, the Roman general and governor of the Judean province at the time, for conquering the Masada complex and putting an end to the Jewish revolt.

Stephen Rutenberg: A Different Perspective on the New Israel Fund Controversy (2015)

on Tisha Ba’v in the year 70 CE, the temple was burned and the population massacred or taken as slaves. On this story the Talmud states that as a consequence of senseless hatred, the temple was destroyed.

Shmarya Rosenberg: Leading Archeologist Says Large Building Stones Heaped At Base Of Temple Mount Near Kotel Not Caused By Destruction Of Second Temple (2015)

The Romans destroyed the Second Temple, but they may not have destroyed the walls surrounding it, a top Israeli archeologist now says.

Shai Secunda: In The Shadow Of Destruction (2011)

“One of the best-known and most cherished stories in rabbinic literature is set in the shadow of a destroyed Jerusalem:” (b. Makkot 24b)

Seth Schwartz on the Significance of AD70 (2015 Video)

AJR interviews Dr. Seth Schwartz in a three-part series about his work, criticism, and most recent Cambridge publication, The Ancient Jews from Alexander to Muhammad.

Second Temple “Gabriel Stone”

All agree that the passage describes an apocalyptic vision of an attack on Jerusalem in which God appears with angels on chariots

Sara Rigler: When God Moved Out – Tisha B’Av and the Truth of Consequences (2007)

Tisha B’Av marks the day when God walked out on us, and took His house with Him.  If we, the Jews of today, cannot muster grief over the calamity of Tisha B’Av, then we can find our point of connection elsewhere

S. Joel Garver: Matthean Apocalypse and the Parable of the Talents (2005)

Those who are honest admit that we do not know who wrote Matthew, when or where. Still, much can be surmised. For instance, Matthew has impressed many as the most “Jewish” of the Gospels in its content, typology (e.g., Jesus as a new Moses), idiom (e.g., “the heavens”), citation of the Hebrew Scriptures, and preoccupation with the Pharisees.

Rome and Jerusalem: The clash of ancient civilisations (2007)

Ostensibly, there was little reason why Judaea and its inhabitants should be more difficult to govern than any other subjugated province.

Rome and Jerusalem at War – The destruction of the Jewish Temple (2015 Audio)

Jerusalem became a brothel and a torture chamber.  And also a shrine.

Roger Pearse: “His blood be upon us”: The use of Mt.27:25 and Acts 4:10 in patristic writers (2015)

Books can be (and have been) written on the general relation of the early Church to the Jews, and it would be too big a subject for an article.  But a list of the places where these two verses specifically are used seemed like a useful thing to attempt.

Robert Travers: The Effect of the Fall of Jerusalem upon the Character of the Pharisees (1917)

Apocalyptic is the true child of prophecy, and became its true representative to the Jews from the unhappy moment when the Law won an absolute autocracy in Judaism, and made the utterance of God-sent prophetic men impossible

Robert Stein: Jesus, the Destruction of Jerusalem, and the Coming of the Son of Man in Luke 21:5-38 (2012)

The reference to there not being left “one stone upon another that will not be thrown down” (21:6) is hyperbolic in nature, since only exaggerated language can do justice to the horrific nature of the events of A.D. 70.

Rivka Nir: The Destruction of Jerusalem and the Idea of Redemption in the Syriac Apocalypse of Baruch (2003)

the Divine promise to Baruch that the Jerusalem that is to be destroyed is not the city that He had promised to inscribe upon the palms of His hands; the burying of the temple vessels in the earth until the end of days

Rebuilding the Temple in AD 363. The Third Temple – Will it be Rebuilt?

Any attempts by the Jews to sacrifice animals again in the Temple can be and was seen by God as a mockery of the Messiah’s death.  God would not allow this in 363 A.D., and He won’t allow it now.

Rabbi Price: Do you have to give up Olam Hazeh to get to Olam Habo? (2000)

  The world wants you to think that certain things are contradictory and you can’t have them both. In reality this is not the case.

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel: The Third Haftarah of Punishment (2001)

Hard upon us is the Fast of Tisha B’Av, the Ninth of Av, the saddest day of the Jewish year.  The day is called that because on it fell the Disaster of the “Meraglim,” the Spies who betrayed HaShem and the Land of Israel, on the verge of the Jewish People’s entry into the Holy Land.

Rabbi Pinchas Frankel: The Prophecy Shall Come True – A Tale of Akiva (2001)

All the time that I had not seen Uriah’s prophecy of destruction (Micha 3:12) come true, I was afraid

Rabbi Klein: Words of Destruction (2017)

When we mourn the Churban HaBayit we do not simply mourn the demolition of the building which housed the Temple; we mourn the spiritual decline which allowed for that destruction to occur.

Rabbi Jochanan ben Zakkai Study Archive

Abba Sikra, the head of the biryoni (rebels, bandits, looters) in Jerusalem, was the son of the sister of Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai.

Rabbi Applies Deuteronomy 28 to Post-AD70 Era (2010)

Kohen saw the cataclysm as a miraculous fulfillment of prophecy found in the book of Deuteronomy – especially chapter 28:23-24.

PJ Miller: Jesus came to fulfill what Israel failed to achieve (2014)

One thing I’ve noticed is throughout the new testament you never see the Jewish people (again) referred to as chosen. Those in the new testament who are now called chosen are of those who follow Jesus

Phillip Vanwinkle: Straight Outta Context – Matthew 24 (2016)

Jesus here mentions the abomination of desolation standing in the holy place—which was the inside part of the temple, so we know he is talking about the temple.

Peter the Rock Study Archive

For the time is come that judgment must begin at the house of God.

 

Paul the Apostle Study Archive

If you are living according to the flesh, you are about to die.

Paul L. Maier: Not One Stone Left Upon Another (2008)

The catastrophic fall of Jerusalem in A.D. 70 forever changed the face of Judaism—and the fate of Christians in the Holy Land.

Ovid Need: King Agrippa’s Speech To the Nationalists (1998)

Had I perceived that you were all zealously disposed to go to war with the Romans, and that the purer and more sincere part of the people did not propose to live in peace, I had not come out to you, nor been so bold as to give you counsel; for all discourses that tend to persuade men to do what they ought to do is superfluous, when the hearers are agreed to do the contrary.

Over 250 academics call on @StateDept to revise its definition of anti-Semitism

“It has been a standard feature of Christian preaching through the ages that the Roman destruction of Jerusalem in 70 was really God’s decisive punishment of the Jewish people for their rejection of Jesus, who had died around the year 30.” – Steve Mason

 

Norman Golb: Newly Discovered Tunnel May Once Have Carried Dead Sea Scrolls (2007)

pottery shards … and coins from the end of the Second Temple period, prior to the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans in … 70 C.E., were discovered in the channel

Norman Golb may be right after all (2006)

Chicago scholar’s long-discredited theory on Dead Sea Scrolls finds support in new archeological dig

Nir Hasson: Jerusalem’s Time Tunnels (2011)

On the final day of the Great Revolt against the Romans, in 70 C.E., as the Temple was going up in flames, the last of the Jewish rebels escaped into the city’s underground sewer system in a desperate attempt to flee the Roman legionnaires. “Those in the sewers were ferreted out, the ground was torn up, and all who were trapped were killed,” reported contemporary historian Flavius Josephus.

Nathaniel Lardner: A Collection of Jewish and Heathen Testimonies to the Truth of the Christian Religion (1730)

He went and sent the impious Titus his son—This is the impious Titus, ‘who blasphemed the Most High, even God himself. What did he do? He took a harlot into the holy of holies, and there lay with her: and he took a sword and cut the veils ; at the same time there was a miracle, for blood burst out: he thought he had killed God himself

Mishnah Study Archive

at the end of the second century CE, when Rabbi Judah the Patriarch was on good terms with the Roman imperial government, he published the Mishnah as a conscious effort to ignore and displace the memories of destruction and loss.

Milton Terry: Apocalyptic Elements in Hebrew Song (1883)

It borders on folly to ask, in the study of such a psalm, when and where God actually bent down the visible heaven and made a pathway of clouds on which David or anyone else saw him descend. But we do see, in all such emo­tional word-pictures, how vividly the Hebrew poets apprehended the presence of God in human experience, and also in the phenomena of the natural world.

Midrash Study Archive

at the end of the second century CE, when Rabbi Judah the Patriarch was on good terms with the Roman imperial government, he published the Mishnah as a conscious effort to ignore and displace the memories of destruction and loss.

Michael Bull: Cosmic Language, or, Ethnic Cleansing as Mercy (2012)

In representative terms, the people of God are no longer the Land but the heavenly Sea. The Church herself is the oncoming storm.

Michael Blume: The Demonic Possession of an Entire Generation (2002)

Revelation reveals the degree of demonic possession that the New Babylon, Jerusalem, experienced after having evil returned with seven devils more worse than itself.

Mesha Stele – Moabite Stone (0830 B.C.)

The inscription reads like a leaf taken out of a lost book of Chronicles. The expressions are the same; the names of gods, kings and of towns are the same.

Matthew the Evangelist Study Archive

Matthew had first preached to Hebrews, and when he was on the point of going to others he transmitted in writing in his native language the Gospel according to himself, and thus supplied by writing the lack of his own presence to those from whom he was sent.

 

Mark the Evangelist Study Archive

From now on, you] shall be seeing the Son of Man sitting at the right hand of Power, and coming on the clouds of heaven

Marcus Booker: New Covenant as Apostolic Midrash (2003)

The apostles generally had no need to explain the original contexts, which were not in dispute. Midrash differs from parable in that parables form a teaching on the basis of a supposed or hypothetical history. The illustrations derived from midrash, on the other hand, have their foundation in factual history.

Lyn Schuldt: Finished by A.D.79: Historical Proof (1997)

A.D.79: All signs described by Jesus happened to the generation to which Jesus spoke some fifty years earlier.

 

Levi Chazen: Forty Years from Jewish Sources

We also find in the case of the punishment of stripes that the Torah teaches us: “Forty shall you strike him, he shall not increase.” Again, forty as a punishment for a person’s sins.

Lee Levine: The Temple Destroyed; The Synagogue Takes a Turn (2007)

To understand the evolution of the synagogue in Roman-occupied Palestine, we interviewed Lee I. Levine, professor of Jewish History and Archaeology at Hebrew University and author of The Ancient Synagogue: The First Thousand Years.

Kollel Hadaf: Thoughts on Sotah, 49 (2002)

this civil war in which the Romans were invited to fight against one of the Jewish armies is what brought about the eventual destruction of Yerushalayim at the hands of Titus.

Ker Than: Dead Sea Scrolls Mystery Solved? (2010)

But new research suggests many of the Dead Sea Scrolls originated elsewhere and were written by multiple Jewish groups, some fleeing the circa-A.D. 70 Roman siege that destroyed the legendary Temple in Jerusalem.

Justin Martyr: Dialogue with Trypho, a Jew (0150)

For if we looked for a human kingdom, we should also deny our Christ, that we might not be slain; and we should strive to escape detection, that we might obtain what we expect. But since our thoughts are not fixed on the present, we are not concerned when men cut us off

Josephus, Wars, Book 6, Chapter 5, Section 3

before sun-setting, chariots and troops of soldiers in their armour were seen running about among the clouds, and surrounding of cities.

Josephus Parallels? The 10 Horns Who Received Authority for “One Hour” (Revelation 17:12)

In this post we will focus on the 10 horns/kings who did not yet have authority when John wrote his book, but who would soon “receive authority for one hour as kings” with the scarlet beast.

Josephus Parallels? Revelation 16:19 and Wars of the Jews 5:1:1

Now the great city was divided into three parts, and the cities of the nations fell. And great Babylon was remembered before God, to give her the cup of the wine of the fierceness of His wrath

Josephus Parallels? Revelation 16:18 and Wars of the Jews 4:4:5

And there were noises and thundering and lightnings; and there was a great earthquake, such a mighty and great earthquake as had not occurred since men were on the earth.

Josephus Parallels? Revelation 16:21 and Wars of the Jews 5:6:3

“And great hail from heaven fell upon men, each hailstone about the weight of a talent.”

John the Apostle Study Archive

the founder of the Præterist School is none other than St. John himself.

John Stevenson: Summary of The First Roman-Jewish War (2003)

The crowd called for a curse to be brought upon themselves and their children. It would be in this same courtyard that the Romans would break through in 70 A.D. and slaughter the unbelieving Jews of Jerusalem.

John Lightfoot: A Commentary of the New Testament from the Talmud and Hebraica (1658)

With the same reference it is, that the times and state of things immediately following the destruction of Jerusalem are called ‘a new creation,’ new heavens,’ and ‘a new earth.’ When should that be? Read the whole chapter; and you will find the Jews rejected and cut off; and from that time is that new creation of the evangelical world among the Gentiles.

John Jahn: History of the Hebrew Commonwealth (1815)

Thus was Jerusalem destroyed with its temple in the second year of Vespasian, A. D. 71, according to the common reckoning, but according to Silberschlag, in the year 74. Josephus expressly says, that the ground was levelled, as though no building had ever stood upon it, according to the prediction of our Saviour in Matt. xxiv. 2.

John Gill:  A Complete Body of Doctrinal and Practical Divinity (1769)

Having treated of the internal and immanent acts in the divine mind, and which are eternal; I shall next consider the operations and transactions among the three divine persons when alone, before the world began, or any creature was in being; and which are, chiefly the council and covenant of God.

Johann Zschokke: The Destruction of Jerusalem (1816)

Judaea, which for some time had enjoyed the appearance of liberty under her own kings, independent of the Romans, was now treated as a mere province—the governors ruled it despotically —they even assumed the custody of the Temple and the right of appointing the High Priest .

Jim Hopkins: Redating the First Deportation of Judah

The only reason for the fabrication of a deportation in the year 606 or 605 BC is the statement of Daniel concerning the third year of the reign of Jehoiakim. But in misunderstanding Daniel’s statement, the credibility of other scriptures is rejected or at least placed in jeopardy.

Jim Bloom: Lion Feuchtwanger and his Josephus Trilogy

I chose therefore to transplant this conflict into the soul of a man, the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, who, it appeared to me, had experienced it in the same way as so many do today, with the difference that he did so 1860 years ago.

Jews for Judaism on the Second Coming of Christ

No amount of Christian theological acrobatics will ever solve the problems engendered by the historical reality that a promised imminent fulfillment made two thousand years ago did not occur as expected by the New Testament. Simply stated, Jesus is never coming back, not then, not now, not ever.

Jesus is Israel Study Archive

Scriptures give the Christ different names. Sometimes they call Him Jacob: ‘Jacob, my son, I will help thee; Israel, my chosen, my soul hath received him, he shall bring judgment unto the nations.’ – Eusebius, AD 312

Jerusalem as Babylon Study Archive

If the City is Jerusalem, how can she be said to wield this kind of worldwide political power?  The answer is that Revelation is not a book about politics; it is a book about the Covenant.  Jerusalem did reign over the nation.

James, The Brother of the Lord Study Archive

Why do ye ask me concerning Jesus, the Son of Man? He himself sitteth in heaven at the right hand of the great Power, and is about to come upon the clouds of heaven.

James Besser: Links to Christian Zionists Pose Peril (2005)

The theology of many Christian Zionists states there can be no peace for Israel until the longed-for ‘second coming’ of Jesus, and that, in fact, the ‘end times’ will include efforts to deceive the world with false promises of peace.

J.E. Lendon: The Roman Siege of Jerusalem (2005)

This article was written by J.E. Lendon and originally published in the Summer 2005 edition of MHQ. J.E. Lendon is an associate professor of history at the University of Virginia. This article is excerpted from his book Soldiers and Ghosts: A History of Battle in Classical Antiquity

Ivan Lewis: The Time of the Destruction of the Temple (2000)

some scholars considered the development of the Law more important than the maintenance of the Temple. They probably reasoned that were the Temple to be destroyed it could be rebuilt in more auspicious times, but if the Torah were neglected it might spell the doom of the Jewish nation.

Isaac Penington: The Jew Outward as a Glass (1659)

Many exceptions and arguments they had against him; against his descent, his doctrine, his practices, his miracles, his followers, &c., which I shall refer to heads, to make them more obvious.

Isaac Penington: Questions And Answers For The Opening Of The Eyes Of The Jews Natural. That They May See The Hope Of Israel (1659)

the law of Moses could not, because of the weakness of the flesh on their parts; let them in fear, and silence of the natural wisdom, and in waiting on the Lord in spirit, consider the Questions and Answers following, relating to spiritual Israel.

Invicta Video: The Siege of Jerusalem (70 AD) – In Four Parts

The Siege of Jerusalem stands out as one of the most brutal examples of Classical Era total war since the fall of Carthage over 200 years earlier!

Hugh Nibley: Christian Envy of the Temple (1959)

Long ago Adam of St. Victor observed with wonder that the Christian fathers had always gone out of their way to avoid any discussion of the tabernacle of God, in spite of its great popular interest and its importance in the divine economy.

Hershel Shanks: The Destruction of Pompeii—God’s Revenge? (2010)

Nine years, almost to the day, after Roman legionaries destroyed God’s house in Jerusalem, God destroyed the luxurious watering holes of the Roman elite. Was this God’s revenge?

 

Herod’s Temple Study Archive

The more thoughtful, however, who refuse to believe that the Creator contrives afflictions to scourge His erring children, will decline to attribute to the anger of God either the horrors that Titus wrought or the horrors that Titus suffered.

Henry Stebbing: Introduction to the Works of Josephus (1842)

The fulfilment of our Lord’s prophecy respecting Jerusalem.. is portrayed in the pages of Josephus with terrible exactness.

Henry Milman: History of the Jews (1830)

By the destruction of Jerusalem and of the fortified cities of Machaerus and Masada, which had held out after it, the political existence of the Jewish nation was annihilated

Harvard House: Scientific Date for Destruction of Herod’s Temple in AD70 (2001)

Astronomy and the secular writings of Josephus enable us to pinpoint the day Rome set fire to Herod’s temple. Astronomy has a natural relationship to Daniel’s “time-oriented” prophecy.

Groups seek to make destruction more relevant to secular Israelis (2007)

Tisha B’Av is marked primarily by the religious and ultra-Orthodox public, who fast and mourn the destruction of the First and Second Temples.

Gregory Sharpe: The Rise and Fall of Jerusalem (1764)

This great event is foretold by almost all the prophets. The destruction of Jerusalem is expressed by The GREAT DAY OF THE LORD

Geza Vermes: The Miraculous Discovery and True Significance of the Dead Sea Scrolls (2010)

 One popular conspiracy theory held that the Catholic scholars who did the initial analysis of the scrolls kept their conclusion secret because it challenged the Christian faith. Mr Vermes, who was close to that research effort, finds good reason to criticise it for slowness and carelessness—but no ground to assert a conspiracy.

Geza Vermes: Jesus in the Eyes of Josephus (2010)

In conclusion, what seems to be Josephus’s authentic portrait of Jesus depicts him as a wise teacher and miracle worker, with an enthusiastic following of Jewish disciples who, despite the crucifixion of their master by order of Pontius Pilate in collusion with the Jerusalem high priests, remained faithful to him up to Josephus’s days.

George Fisher: Differentiating Judaism from Christianity (1890)

The title of the Jews to peculiar and exclusive privileges in the community of Christian believers was set aside. The demand that the Christian believer should come into the Church through the door of Judaism, by conforming to the rites ordained for heathen proselytes, was no longer made.

Geoffrey Grinder: The Six Seals of Revelation 6 and Matthew 24 In Order (2015)

There is an astounding connection between what Jesus is teaching in Matthew 24 about the time of the Tribulation, and with what John sees in Revelation 6 about the same period of time.

Gary DeMar: Flavius Josephus and Preterism (2013)

While the Bible is the best interpreter of itself, it helps to have non-biblical historical sources from the same time period to help flesh out details not found in Scripture and to support what is found in the biblical text. The writings of Josephus are some of those historical works. We would be foolish to ignore them.

G.J. Goldberg: Monty Python and the Works of Josephus (2004)

Despite the aqueduct, which Pilate in any case paid for with funds stolen from the Jerusalem Temple, Josephus does not give the Romans much credit for enhancing life in Judea.

G.J. Goldberg: Josephus and The Star of Bethlehem (1999)

I have suggested that in 66 CE, “pretended messengers of the deity” (War 6.5.3 288) spoke of the sign as “standing over” the Temple and as predicting the coming of the Messiah (War 6.5.4 313).

Fourth Ezra (0080)

The main body of the book appears to be written for consolation in a period of great distress (most likely Titus’ destruction of the Second Temple in AD 70) according to the modern theory.  The author seeks answers, similar to Job’s quest for understanding the meaning of suffering but the author doesn’t like or desire only the answer that was given to Job.

First Baruch, King James Bible

To bring upon us great plagues, such as never happened under the whole heaven, as it came to pass in Jerusalem, according to the things that were written in the law of Moses

F. Paul Peterson: Peter’s Tomb Found in Jerusalem (1960)

I have a letter from a noted scientist stating that he can tell by the writing that it was written just before the destruction of Jerusalem by Titus in 70 A.D.

Ezekiel 38:2 Study Archive

Son of man, set thy face against Gog, the land of Magog, the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal, and prophesy against him

 

Expository Glossary of Hebraic Terms used in Messianic Teaching

Behold, the Lord cometh forth out of his place, and will come down.. And the mountains shall be molten under him, and the valleys shall be as wax before the fire, and as the waters that are poured down a steep place

Evidence of the crossing of the Red Sea

Depth-sounding expeditions have revealed a smooth, gentle slope descending from Nuweiba out into the Gulf.

 

Ernest L. Martin: The Seven Hills of Jerusalem (2000)

Those “seven hills” are easy to identify. If one starts with the Mount of Olives just to the east of the main City of Jerusalem (but still reckoned to be located within the environs of Jerusalem), there are three summits to that Mount of Olives.

Duncan McKenzie: The Revelation of Jesus Christ (2007)

Hello again, my friends. With the understanding that God has made us bread to be broken and shared with the eater, I thought I’d sit down and break you off a little.

Dominic Selwood: Two millennia after the sack of Jerusalem (2014)

Joseph, or Josephus as be became known, lived through the most turbulent period of the Jewish-Roman wars, and — to the joy of later historians — loved writing as much as he enjoyed talking about himself… his boastful personality is inextricably linked to the extraordinary life he led, and to his unique closeness to the decision makers on both sides of the war. Whatever one thinks of his character or actions, his eye for detail and his fascination with the politics driving Rome and Jerusalem make him one of the most immediate and exciting writers of the first century.

Dead Sea Scrolls: 4QH (Thanksgiving Hymns)

Their weapons of evil engulf the land like a tidal wave upon the shore. Like a wave of destruction devouring a multitude of men.

Dead Sea Scrolls: 4Q266-273 ; CD (Damascus Document)

From the day of the gathering in of the Teacher of the Community until the end of all the men of war who deserted to the Liar, there shall pass about forty years.

Dead Sea Scrolls: 4Q179 (Pesher Nahum)

from Antiochus until the appearance of the rulers of the Kittim. And afterwards the city shall be trampled

Dead Sea Scrolls: 4Q171 (Pesher Psalms)

Its pesher refers to all wickedness at the end of 40 years (Heb:Mem = 40). They will be finished and no wicked man will be found on the earth.

 

Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QS (The Community Rule)

the community itself expresses its self-understanding as the new covenant community of the Last Days.

Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QpHab (Pesher Habakkuk)

Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QM, 4Q491-496 (The War Scroll)

And the dominion of the Kittim shall come to an end, so that wickedness shall be laid low without any remnant; and there shall be no survivor of the sons of darkness.

Dead Sea Scrolls: 1Q16 (Pesher Psalms)

You have rebuked [the swamp beast,] that herd of bulls, the Gentile heifers; he tramples on bars of silver

Dead Sea Scrolls 1Q71-72 ; 6Q7 ; 4Q243 (The Book of Daniel)

This was fantastic news from a scholarly point of view, for the text of Daniel has long been considered suspect by many scholars on various grounds

David Turner: Christian Insecurity: The Problem of the Second Coming (2014)

If Paul, the “father” of the religion was wrong about Jesus Return then where does that leave Paul’s promise of Eternal Life in Jesus? And if even Jesus, Son of God and the Christ was mistaken… Does Christianity just come down to a roll of dice, another instance of Pascal’s Wager?

David Padfield: Days of Vengeance (2011)

This book is a very detailed examination of the destruction of Jerusalem and a look at the events which followed.

David Friedman: Does 1 Corinthians 15 Teach a Physical or a Spiritual Resurrection? (2000)

 

Verses 12-16 supports the non-physical interpretation of the resurrection, which claims that the resurrection of Jesus was a time when His followers rose from their despondence to come to the realization that Christ was eternal in being, and that He was still present with them.

David Eidensohn: Rabbi David on Modern Judaism (2003)

After the Destruction of the Second Temple in 70 CE, the various groups disappeared, and only the Orthodox Talmudic sect survived. However, the problems of the exile wore away the Jewish people in several directions.

David Ben-Abraham: Calibrating the Year of the 2nd Temple’s Destruction (2010)

Behold, the Lord cometh forth out of his place, and will come down.. And the mountains shall be molten under him, and the valleys shall be as wax before the fire, and as the waters that are poured down a steep place

Daniel Silvestri: All Jewish Festivals Are Fulfilled! (1998)

I agree that Jesus’ “appearing a second time” is wrapped up in the Judaic law, but to think we continue to wait for atonement of sin and to be in the presence and tabernacle with God is simply not Biblical.

Daniel 12:2 Study Archive

And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt

 

Damien Mackey: Simon Bar Kochba Dated Too Late (2014)

The nail in the coffin of the textbook history for these times is that Simon Bar Kochba issued coins depicting “The Redemption of Israel” – oh, yes, and so did Simon Bar Giora

Damien Mackey: Crucifixion of Jesus Christ and “Last Judgement of Sanhedrin” (2014)

Forty years before the destruction of the Temple in 70 A.D. is 30 A.D. – the very year of the crucifixion of the Messiah! Why was the Sanhedrin moved in the very year Jesus was crucified?

Daily Telegraph: Two Millennia after the Sack of Jerusalem, what does History tell us? (2014)

Whatever one thinks of his character or actions, his eye for detail and his fascination with the politics driving Rome and Jerusalem make him one of the most immediate and exciting writers of the first century.

Cyprian: Testimonies Against the Jews (0200-58)

I have endeavoured to show that the Jews, according to what had before been foretold, had departed from God, and had lost God’s favour, which had been given them in past time, and had been promised them for the future; while the Christians had succeeded to their place, deserving well of the Lord by faith, and coming out of all nations and from the whole world.

Chrysostom: Homilies Against the Jews (0386)

This is what God did. He saw the Jews choking with their mad yearning for sacrifices. He saw that they were ready to go over to idols if they were deprived of sacrifices. I should say, he saw that they were not only ready to go over, but that they lad already done so.

Charles Dudley Warner: Jerusalem (1876)

Perhaps it was a mistake to go there at all; certainly I should have waited until I had become more accustomed to holy places.

Carl Hagensick: The Ninth of Ab (1996)

Today the ninth day of the Jewish month Ab (July-August on our calendar) is commemorated as a national day of misfortune for Israel. It is a day of fasting.

Brian King: The Presence of Eschatology and Apocalypticism in the Teaching of Jesus Christ (1999)

For most biblical scholars, the delay of the Second Coming of the Messiah “was the single most important factor for the transformation of early Christian eschatology from an emphasis on the imminent expectation of the end to a vague expectation set in the more distant future

Bibliography: Early Apocalyptic Preterism (150BC-AD150)

The next line, however, begins, “Its interpretation concerns the Kittim….” The modern theory had already been propounded by interpretation by the ancient community two thousand years earlier!

 

Bibliography: All PDF Files in the Preterist Archive (4/19/19)

• These files have been assembled over the last 25 years, and the archive is still growing.  All are welcomed to take advantage of this page’s centuries of knowledge related to first century studies and fulfilled prophecy.

 

Benedict XVI criticised for new article on Jewish-Christian relations (2018)

“Both theses — that Israel was not replaced by the Church and that the Covenant was never revoked — are basically correct, but in many respects inaccurate and therefore require further thought,” Benedict said.

Ben Johnson: The Parable of the Wicked Tenants in in the Light of Second Temple Jewish Parallels (2009)

Jesus’ Interpretation of the Song of the Vineyard in the Light of Second Temple Jewish Parallels

BAR: Arch of Titus and Colosseum detail destruction of Jerusalem Temple (2013)

the construction of the amphitheater was financed by the plundered booty from the Jewish Revolt.

Avraham Zuroff: Jews to Recite Rare Sun Blessing at Masada’s Ancient Synagogue (2009)

For the first time in two thousand years, the ancient synagogue atop the Judean desert fortress of Masada will ring out at dawn with the rare blessing of the sun.

Avishai Maraglit: Titus Flavius Josephus and the Prophet Jeremiah (2015)

Josephus’s relation to power should not disqualify him as a witness in the court of history but it does disqualify him as a moral witness: a moral witness is never in the service of the ruling power.

Archeological Jackpot in Jerusalem: Ancient Canal Uncovered (2007)

The Israel Antiquities Authority announced Sunday that it found the site which served as a backdrop for a famous scene in the Great Jewish Rebellion against Rome

Archaeologists Uncover Possible Royal Escape Tunnel at Biblical Site (2015)

in 2014, a rare Judaea capta coin was discovered, a coin minted by Emperor Domitian between 81 and 96 CE to commemorate the conquest of Judaea and destruction of Jerusalem in 70 CE by emperors Vespasian and Titus.

Archaeologists find battle site where Romans breached Jerusalem walls (2016)

They said that the discovery, made last winter during an excavation of a construction site for the new campus of the Bezalel Academy of Arts and Design outside the Old City, also finally confirmed the description of the wall that was breached provided by the historian Josephus Flavius.

Apocrypha Study Archive

 The Apocrypha (Greek, “hidden books”) are Jewish books from 13th – 3rd centuries BC not preserved in the Tanakh, but included in the Latin (Vulgate) and Greek (Septuagint) Old Testaments.

Antisemitism Study Archive

If we are seeking a reasonable definition of the word antisemitism, then Christian Zionism is here accused of being inherently antisemitic.

Ancient Tunnels From Second Jewish Revolt Discovered in Jerusalem (2006)

A series of underground chambers and tunnels recently found in Israel were likely used as refuges during the First Jewish Revolt, archaeologists with the Israel Antiquities Authority announced.

Altman-Crowder: Jewish Talmud Confirms an Early Gospel of Matthew (2003)

a literary tale dated by some scholars at 72 AD or earlier, which comes from an ancient collection of Jewish writings known as the Talmud, quotes brief passages that appear only in the Gospel of Matthew.

Alfred Edersheim: Sketches of Jewish Social Life in the Time of Jesus (1876)

Probably most readers would wish to know something more of those “traditions” to which our Lord so often referred in His teaching. We have here to distinguish, in the first place, between the Mishnah and the Gemara.

Adam Maarschalk: The Historical Events Leading Up to 70 AD (2009)

a fascinating timeline of these events, beginning with the martyrdom of James, the brother of Jesus.

Adam Maarschalk: Josephus and the Book of Revelation – Nine Case Studies (2016)

As we look at these parallels, consider what they mean for the popular idea that John wrote Revelation around 95 AD. Some of the parallels are so striking that a person would basically have to conclude that John borrowed from the earlier writings of Josephus, and then used the language of Josephus to prophesy of a much later war

Adam Clarke: Commentary on Matthew 24 (1810)

The temple was destroyed 1st. Justly; because of the sins of the Jews.  2dly. Mercifully; to take away from them the occasion of continuing in Judaism: and 3dly. Mysteriously; to show that the ancient sacrifices were abolished, and that the whole Jewish economy was brought to an end, and the Christian dispensation introduced.

Abraham Rabinovich: Stone Piles that Memorialize Jerusalem’s Destruction (1997)

The tableau is a 2,000-year-old scream frozen in stone at its moment of issue — the fall of Jerusalem.

A Kuenen : The Religion of Israel to the Fall of the Jewish State (1874)

The history of Judaism is a reflection of that of Islam and of Christianity and not the converse.

2,000 Year Old Hebrew Document Written on Papyrus Seized (2009)

one can clearly read the sentence “Year 4 to the destruction of Israel”. This is likely to be the year 74 CE – in the event the author of the document is referring to the year when the Second Temple was destroyed during the Great Revolt.

---

PHASE ONE (UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019) THE BOOKS OF MOSES Genesis Exodus Leviticus Numbers Deuteronomy FORMER PROPHETS Joshua Judges Ruth 1 Samuel 2 Samuel 1 Kings 2 Kings 1 Chronicles 2 Chronicles Ezra Nehemiah Esther Job THE WISDOM LITERATURE Psalms Proverbs Ecclesiastes Song of Solomon THE LATTER PROPHETS MAJOR Nevi’im Isaiah Jeremiah Ezekiel Ketuvim  Lamentations Daniel MINOR Hosea Joel Amos Obadiah Jonah Micah Nahum Habakkuk Zephaniah Haggai Zechariah Malachi As to the cause of the cessation of prophecy at that time there are various opinions. “Hitherto prophets, inspired by the holy spirit, addressed the nation; henceforth, ‘Incline thine ear and listen to the words of wise me, for it is pleasant to keep them in thy heart.’ – Rabbi Jose ben Halafta APOCRYPHAL DEUTEROCANONICAL Baruch The Letter of Jeremiah Tobit Judith Additions to the Book of Esther Wisdom of Solomon Ecclesiasticus, or the Wisdom of Jesus Son of Sirach The Prayer of Azariah and the Song of the Three Jews Susanna Bel and the Dragon 1 Maccabees 2 Maccabees GREEK AND SLAVONIC CANON 1 Esdras 2 Esdras 3 Maccabees 4 Maccabees Prayer of Manasseh Psalm 151 ADDITIONAL WORKS 2 Baruch

PHASE TWO (UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019) 1856: Alfred Edersheim, History of the Jewish Nation After AD70 1856: Morris J. Raphall, Post-Biblical History of the Jews, From the Close of the Old Testament till the Destruction of the Second Temple, V1 | V2 (pdf) 1906: Shailer Mathews, The History of Palestine in New Testament Times 1956: Franz Kobler, A History of the British Movement for the Restoration of the Jews to Palestine – The establishment of the State of Israel may be rightly looked upon as the greatest collective achievement of the Jewish people in the history of the Diaspora. There is, however, a non-Jewish element hidden in the Restoration of Israel. 2005: Stephen Sizer, Christian Zionism: Its History, Theology, and Politics

---

(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

---

“Jewish writings stipulate that forty years after the coming of the Messiah there will be a resurrection of the dead, and all who are lying in dust will rise to new life.”

• History through a Jewish lens, The War of Tisha B’av  (http,//www.dafka.org/NewsGen.asp?S=4&PageID=1089) – This translation comes from my Artscroll edition of the Chumash, pages 1081 and 1085.  First, Devarim/Deuteronomy 28,49-50,   HaShem will carry against you a nation from afar, from the end of the earth, as an eagle will swoop, a nation whose language you will not understand, a brazen nation that will not be respectful to the old nor gracious to the young.  Rambam comments on Deuteronomy 28,49 that Vespasian and his son Titus came from Rome to conquer the Land of Israel and destroy Jerusalem and the Second Temple.  The awful conditions described though verse 57 took place during the siege of Jerusalem.  A yeshiva student studying these lines in Warsaw on the night of Wednesday, August 30, 1939, would have read Rambam in the Hebrew, saying exactly what I quoted you.  However, if he had time to follow the reading of the Torah in shul (synagogue) on September 2 and could concentrate upon it, instead of the screaming of the Luftwaffe overhead, he might have had a very different comprehension of these same lines.

• Mikra’ot Gedolot
• Babylonian Talmud and the students of the Talmud – “Three and a half million words of the uncensored Talmud on line, with discussions on its place in the modern world by Elizabeth Dilling, Rabbi Dr. J. H. Hertz, Rabbi Dr. I. Epstein, Rabbi Michael Rodkinson, Rabbi Israel Brodie, Rabbi Dr. Louis Finkelstein, and many other Talmud luminaries, Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform — and your hostess, Carol A. Valentine. This website is inspired by Rabbi Professor Jonathan Sacks, Chief Rabbi of the British Commonwealth, and to a lesser extent, the current President of the United States, George Bush. We are dedicated to bringing about understanding between people of different faiths.”
• Lewis Ginzberg: The Legends of the Jews
• Hebraic Literature: Translations from Talmud Midrashim and Kabbala
• Samuel M. Schmucker: A History of the Modern Jews; or, Annals of the Hebrew Race From the Destruction of Jerusalem to the Present Time (1867)

Why Was Temple Destroyed?: Michel Wex Haaretz Interview – Scholar and popularizer of Yiddish, whose latest offering draws from two millennia of Jewish tradition to serve as a primer for being a mentsh “You look at something like the story in the Talmud about the destruction of Jerusalem, about Kamtso and Bar Kamtso. Ultimately it turned on a piece of khnoykishkayt [hypocritical sanctimoniousness]” // Wex focuses on the Talmudic explanation for the destruction of the Second Temple, which is attributed to a feud between two Jews of firstcentury C.E. Jerusalem. The servant of a man throwing a party mistakenly invites Bar Kamtso, an enemy of his boss, instead of his friend Kamtso. The host, rather than making the best of an awkward situation, pointedly refuses to admit Bar Kamtso when he shows up at the gathering. An embarrassed Bar Kamtso offers to cover the cost of the entire party if he is only allowed to stay, but the host kicks him out, humiliating him before his peers, none of whom bothers to come to his defense. Bar Kamtso decides to take his revenge by sabotaging an offering of a calf that the Roman emperor has sent to the Temple. In a fatal display of small-minded pettiness, the Temple’s priests refuse to accept the blemished offering, thereby insulting the emperor, who then orders the city attacked and the Temple destroyed.  In Michael Wex’s − and the Talmud’s − eyes, everyone involved in the tale behaved badly, schmuckishly in fact, and with devastating consequences. Each character allows his anger to get the better of him − and self-control, the author argues, is one of the most basic lessons of Judaism.

The Generation of the Messiah | The Ninth of Ab | Daniel’s Weeks Prophecy | The Heavenly Temple | The Destruction of the Temple | New Heavens and Earth | Symbols for Rome

Significance of Forty Year Period
c.f. – A.D. 30 (Death of Christ) to A.D.70 (Fall of Jerusalem)

---

‘THE GENERATION OF THE MESSIAH’
(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

Maimonides
“Jewish writings stipulate that forty years after the coming of the Messiah there will be a resurrection of the dead, and all who are lying in dust will rise to new life.” (The 13 Principles and the Resurrection of the Dead)

The Rebbe often quotes the Zohar to the effect that the Resurrection will take place 40 years after the advent of Mashiach. (See Igros Kodesh, Vol. II, p. 75; Sefer HaSichos 5752, Vol. I, p. 274. However, there are also other references in the sichos (e.g., Likkutei Sichos, Vol. XXVII, p. 206; Sefer HaSichos 5733, Shabbos Parshas Balak, footnote 3)

THE NINTH OF AB

Misu. Taanith
“On the “ninth of Ab” it was decreed concerning our fathers, that they should not enter into the land (of Canaan), the first and second temple were destroyed, Bither was taken, and the city ploughed up.” (Misu. Taanith, c. 4. sect. 7. T. Hieros. Taanioth, fol. 68. 3. & Maimon. Hilch. Taanioth, c. 5. sect. 2.)

Rabbi Yochanan
“Had I been alive in that generation, I would have fixed [the day of mourning] for the tenth [of Av], because the greater part of the Temple was burnt on that day.” ( The 10th of Av:When the Temple was in Flames)

DANIEL’S WEEKS PROPHECY

Aquila
“On thy people, and on thy sacred city.. For ending disobedience, and for completing transgression. For the fulfilling of their disobedience and the completion of their sin, For the propitiation of their transgression, For the bringing in of everlasting righteousness, And for fulfilling the vision and the prophet. For the anointing of the most consecrated,”  (Quoted inDemonstratio Evangelica (Proof of the Gospel) ;  BOOK VIII)

Josephus
“A sufficient proof of this is afforded by the passage, Josephus Arch. 10:1 l, 7, ‘Daniel predicted also the Roman supremacy, and that our country should be desolated by them.’

Rabbi Judah (Main Compiler of the Talmud)
“These times were over long ago” (Regarding Daniel’s prophecy – Babylonian Talmud Sanhedrin 98b and 97a)

Rabbi Moses Abraham Levi
“I have examined and searched all the Holy Scriptures and have not found the time for the coming of Messiah clearly fixed, except in the words of Gabriel to the prophet Daniel, which are written in the 9th chapter of the prophecy of Daniel.”

Samuel Levine (1925)
“Christians, for lack of a better answer, claim that the 70th week will take place when Jesus returns in his second coming as a king.  The problem was caused because Daniel mentioned a total of 70 weeks, and then he specified 7 plus 62, leaving one remaining.  The Christians say that the first 69 weeks were consecutive, then there is at least a 1900 year gap, and sooner or later the 70th week will occur.  This is obviously a very forced explanation, born of desperation.” [You take Jesus, I’ll Take God: How to Refute Christian Missionaries (Los Angeles: Hamoroh Press, 1980)p. 31]

The Four Kingdoms in Book 4 of the Sibylline Oracles:

1. The Assyrians for 6 generations-49-53
2. The Medes for two generations-54-64
3. The Persians for one generation prosperous-65-87
4. The Macedonians-88-101
   The rise of Italy, Rome-102-114
   The destruction of Jerusalem-115-129
   Rumors of Nero’s return-130-151
   Impiety of end Times-152-161
   Exhortation to convert-162-170
   Conflagration-171-178
   Resurrection & Judgment-179-192

THE DESTRUCTION OF THE SECOND TEMPLE

“from the time that the temple was destroyed, the wise men, and sons of nobles, were put to shame, and they covered their heads; liberal men were reduced to poverty; and men of violence and calumny prevailed; and there were none that expounded, or inquired, or asked. R. Elezer the great, said, from the time the sanctuary were destroyed, the wise men began to be like Scribes, and the Scribes like to the Chazans, (or sextons that looked after the synagogues,) and the Chazans like to the common people, and the common people grew worse and worse, and there were none that inquired and asked;” (Misn. Sotah, c. 9. sect. 15.)

THE HEAVENLY TEMPLE
(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

Midrash on Nathan’s Prophecy (Qumran)
“It is the house which [He will create] for [himself at the E]nd of days, as it is written in the book of [Moses the sanctuary of] the Lord, which Thy hands have established.  The Lord will reign forever and ever..” (DJD V [1968]: 53)

Soncino Zohar, Shemoth, Section 2, Page 149a
“… the structure of the Tabernacle corresponds to the structure of heaven and earth.”

Soncino Zohar, Shemoth, Section 2, Page 231a
“Now, the Tabernacle below was likewise made after the pattern of the supernal Tabernacle in all its details. For the Tabernacle in all its works embraced all the works and achievements of the upper world and the lower, whereby the Shekinah was made to abide in the world, both in the higher spheres and the lower. Similarly, the Lower Paradise is made after the pattern of the Upper Paradise, and the latter contains all the varieties of forms and images to be found in the former. Hence the work of the Tabernacle, and that of heaven and earth, come under one and the same mystery.”

Soncino Zohar, Shemoth, Section 2, Page 235b
“Now, the lower and earthly Tabernacle was the counterpart of the upper Tabernacle, whilst the latter in its turn is the counterpart of a higher Tabernacle, the most high of all. All of them, however, are implied within each other and form one complete whole, as it says: “that the tabernacle may be one whole” (Ex. XXVI, 6). The Tabernacle was erected by Moses, he alone being allowed to raise it up, as only a husband may raise up his wife. With the erection of the lower Tabernacle there was erected another Tabernacle on high. This is indicated in the words “the tabernacle was reared up (hukam)” (Ex. XL, 17), reared up, that is, by the hand of no man, but as out of the supernal undisclosed mystery in response to the mystical force indwelling in Moses that it might be perfected with him.”

Menacoth 29a
“It was taught: R. Jose b. Judah says, An ark of fire and a table of fire and a candlestick of fire came down from heaven; and these Moses saw and reproduced, as it is written, And see that thou make them after their pattern, which is being shown thee in the mount. Will you then say the same [of the tabernacle], for it is written, And thou shalt rear up the tabernacle according to the fashion thereof which hath been shown thee in the mount! — Here it is written ‘according to the fashion thereof’, whilst there ‘after their pattern’.”

b.Hag. 12b
“ZEBUL is that in which [the heavenly] Jerusalem and the [heavenly] Temple and the Alter are built, and Michael, the great Prince, stands and offers up thereon an offering, for it is said: I have surely built you a house of habitation [ZEBUL] a place for you to dwell in forever (1Kn. 8:13) And where do we derive that it is called heaven? For it is written: Look down from heaven, and see, even from your holy and glorious habitation. (Is. 63:15)

Soncino Zohar, Shemoth, Section 2, Page 164a
“Then he began to expound to them this verse: A song of degrees for Solomon (li-shelomoh). Except the Lord build the house, they labour in vain that build it; except the Lord guard the city, the watchman waketh but in vain (Ps. CXXVII, 1-2). Said he: ‘Was it Solomon who composed this Psalm when he built the Temple? (for li-shelomoh could be understood to mean “of Solomon”). Not so. It was King David who composed it, about his son Solomon, when Nathan came to him (David) and told him that Solomon would build the Temple. Then King David showed unto his son Solomon, as a model, the celestial prototype of the Temple, and David himself, when he saw it and all the activities connected with it, as set forth in the celestial idea of it, sang this psalm concerning his son Solomon.

RoshHaShannah 24b
“Abaye replied: The Torah forbade only those attendants of which it is possible to make copies, as it has been taught: A man may not make a house in the form of the Temple, or an exedra in the form of the Temple hall, or a court corresponding to the Temple court, or a table corresponding to the [sacred] table or a candlestick corresponding to the [sacred] candlestick, but he may make one with five or six or eight lamps, but with seven he should not make, even of other metals.”

4. Ta’an 4.8
   “the Holy of Holies below is aligned opposite the Holy of Holies above”

Yitzhak Baer
“The most essential principle in the worldview of our forefathers was that the lower world serves only as a reflection of the upper world.  There follow from this the details of their human Torah, both universal and individual, and their outlook regarding the place of the Jewish people in history; and one cannot separate between these two aspects.” (Yisra’el ba’Amim, 83-84)

Haamek Davar
“A faithful God, never false, just and upright is He”… these praises are intended to justify God’s destruction of the two temples, as will be explained: “A faithful God, never false” – referring to the destruction of the first and second temples, “just and upright is He”– referring to the destruction of the first and second temples …It is known that the first destruction was due to idolatry, sexual immorality, and the shedding of blood which angered The Holy One, Blessed Be He; the second temple was destroyed because of baseless hatred, and we have explained (Bemidbar 35:34) that they did practice study of Torah and the service of God, but most of the shedding of blood was done for the sake of heaven, for they would condemn one who commits some transgression as being a Saduccee, one worthy of death and incarceration, etc. In this, their behavior became very corrupted – all in the name of heaven… “never false” – even though they acted for the sake of heaven, He cannot bear iniquity.”  (Rashi, Devarim 32:4)

Flavius Josephus
“and the Temple shall be made according to the measure and the vessels that he Himself showed him.” (Ant. 3.99-101)

Rivka Nir (2003)
“One may also include within this group (pseudepigraphic-apocalyptic literature) the literature of the Qumran sect, which expresses conceptual and linguistic relations and ideological and theological characteristics similar to those of the pseudepigraphic and apocalyptic literature.  Like the apocalyptic literature, the Qumran sect’s theological focus was on the eschatological anticipation of the approaching end of days, on the war between the forces of light and the forces of darkness, and on the appearance of the expected messianic age.  Similar to the apocalyptic literature, the Qumran scrolls expressed absolute negation of the historical Jerusalem and temple.  The sect anticipates a new Jerusalem and a new temple in which atonement will be achieved, not by means of the flesh of burnt-offerings and the fat of the sacrifices, but by  a spiritual sacrifice “of lips of justice like a righteous fragrance” (1QS ix 4-5).  The scrolls of this mysterious sect also include chapters and fragments of works from the apocalyptic literature (such as the Book of Enoch, the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, the Book of Jubilees, etc.), which likewise betray an ideological proximity to the world of Christianity.” (The Destruction of Jerusalem and the idea of Redemption, p. 13)

“The Jerusalem that God promised to engrave on the palms of His hand is not the Jerusalem that is about to be destroyed, the historic Jerusalem of the Second Temple.  Rather, he refers here to another Jerusalem, one kept by God in the heavens, which He himself created before time, alongside paradise — a transcendent and preexistent Jerusalem.” (p. 20)

“The author of this book is not at all interested in the rebuilding of the temple and of Jerusalem; indeed, not a word is said in the entire book regarding the hope and anticipation for its future restoration.  According to his view, the historical Jerusalem and temple, which were built by man on earth, were from the outset inferior and condemned to a limited life span, as against the heavenly Jerusalem and sanctuary, which were formed by God in hoary antiquity and will enjoy eternal existence.” (p. 21)

Philo of Alexandria
“It was determined, therefore, to fashion a tabernacle, a work of the highest sanctity, the construction of which was set forth to Moses on the mount  by divine pronouncements.  He saw with the soul’s eye the immaterial forms of the material objects about to be made, and these forms had to be reproduced in copies, perceived by the senses, taken from the original draught, so to speak, and from patterns comprehended in the mind.. So the shape of the model was stamped upon the mind of the prophet, a secretly painted or moulded prototype, produced by immaterial and invisible forms; and then the resulting work was built in accordance with that shape by the artist impressing the stampings upon the material substances required in each case.” (Mos. 2.74-76 [LCL; 6:485-87])

Rabbi Yochanan
“Yerushalayim was destroyed only because they ruled according to the law of the Torah.”  What? Are we then to judge according to the laws of the gentiles?!  Rather say “Because they based their law on the law of the Torah and did not act beyond the letter of the law.  (Bavli, Bava Metsia 30b).

Ethiopian Book of Enoch
“Then I stood still, looking at that ancient house being transformed: all the pillars and all the columns were pulled out; and the ornaments of that house were packed and taken out together with them and abandoned in a certain place in the South of the land.  I went on seeing until the Lord of the sheep brought about a new house, greater and loftier than the first one, and set it up in the first location which had been covered up — all its pillars were new, the columns new; and the ornaments new, as well as greater than those of the first, (that is) the old (house), which was gone.  All the sheep were within it.” (I En. 90:28-29)

Testament of Dan
“and the saints shall refresh themselves in Eden, the righteous shall rejoice in the new Jerusalem, which shall be eternally for the glorification of God.” (Test. Dan 5:12)

THE NEW HEAVENS AND EARTH
(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

“For Behold — from the great goodness that there will be, as if the world will be renewed, a new heavens and a new earth”

Maimonides
“Thus describing the state of Exile and its various particularities and thereupon the restoration of the kingdom and the disappearance of all those sorrows, he says, speaking in parables:  I shall create another heaven and another earth and those that are now will be forgotten and their traces effaced.  Then he explains this in continuity, saying: When I have said “I shall create,” I meant thereby that I shall produce for you, instead of those sorrows and hardships, a state of constant joy and gladness so that the former sorrows will not be remembered.” (Guide for the Perplexed II.29)

Rome in Jewish Sources

ON DEUTERONOMY 28:49

“Trajan, being sent for by his wife to subdue the Jews, determined to come in ten days, and came in five; he came and found them (the Jews) busy in the law on that verse, “the Lord shall bring a nation against thee from far”, &c. he said unto them, what are ye busy in? they answered him, so and so; he replied to them, this is the man (meaning himself) who thought to come in ten days, and came in five; and he surrounded them with his legions, and slew them:” (T. Hieros. Succah, fol. 55. 2.)

Rambam
“Vespasian and his son Titus came from Rome to conquer the Land of Israel and destroy Jerusalem and the Second Temple.  The awful conditions described though verse 57 took place during the siege of Jerusalem.” (History through a Jewish lens: The War of Tisha B’av)

ROME AS KITTIM

Ida Froehlich (1999)
“The rule for the use of t he typological name Kittim –and most probably for other terms as well– is that the name has a collective, general meaning (in the case of the Kittim: “strangers arriving from the sea, from the direction of Cyprus”). The actual meaning of the name in a given instance is always determined by the characteristics of the term, that is, those events which the text mentions as a reference in connection with the name (sometimes, as in the case of Acco in the aforementioned text, one key word is the determining factor).

The kittim mentioned in pHab are to be identified with the Romans. Pesher Habakkuq IX.4-10 interprets the conquest of the kittim as divine punishment, in the course of which “the riches and booty of the last priests (_____ _¿______) of Jerusalem shall l be delivered into the hands of the army of the Kittim”, “at the end of the days (_¿____ _____)”. This reference most likely concerns the fight for the throne between the sons of Alexandros Jannaios, in the course of which both pretenders gave handsome sums and gifts to Aemilius Scaurus, the Roman general, and Pompeius, who was the arbiter in their dispute (cf. Jos. Ant. XIV.2-3; 3.1).” (History as seen from Qumran)

Rivka Nir (2003)
“One may also include within this group (pseudepigraphic-apocalyptic literature) the literature of the Qumran sect, which expresses conceptual and linguistic relations and ideological and theological characteristics similar to those of the pseudepigraphic and apocalyptic literature.  Like the apocalyptic literature, the Qumran sect’s theological focus was on the eschatological anticipation of the approaching end of days, on the war between the forces of light and the forces of darkness, and on the appearance of the expected messianic age.  Similar to the apocalyptic literature, the Qumran scrolls expressed absolute negation of the historical Jerusalem and temple.  The sect anticipates a new Jerusalem and a new temple in which atonement will be achieved, not by means of the flesh of burnt-offerings and the fat of the sacrifices, but by  a spiritual sacrifice “of lips of justice like a righteous fragrance” (1QS ix 4-5).  The scrolls of this mysterious sect also include chapters and fragments of works from the apocalyptic literature (such as the Book of Enoch, the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, the Book of Jubilees, etc.), which likewise betray an ideological proximity to the world of Christianity.” (The Destruction of Jerusalem and the idea of Redemption, p. 13)

Peter Schafer (2003)
“One thing both movements (Qumran and Bar Kochba) would have had in common was the fight against Rome, for it is almost certain that the term “Kittim” in the Qumran texts stemming from the final phase of the Qumran community is a reference to the Romans.” (The History of the Jews in the Greco-Roman World, p. 152)

Nosson Scherman (1994)
(On Daniel 11:30) “Kittim is another name for the Romans.  Rome will ignore its prior pact with the Hasmoneans (v. 23), and nullify the treaty.   It will realize that Jewish disunity, brought about by their forsaking the Torah, “the Covenant of Sanctity,” provides Rome the opportunity to conquer.” (Tanach, p. 1808)

Lawrence Schiffman (2001)
“For many years, the Dead Sea sect had expected the Roman conquest of Palestine.  The Dead Sea sectarians felt confident that the coming of the Kittim – as they called the Romans – would trigger the great eschatological battle.  But this final, expected war failed to materialize after the Romans easily defeated the divided Hasmonaean state in 63 B.C.E.  By the time Jewish resistance developed into the full-scale revolt of 66-73 C.E., the Dead Sea sect had stabilized and had completed the gathering – with some possible exception – of its manuscript collection at Qumran.”  (Reclaiming the Dead Sea Scroll, p. 395)

Kittim – A place-name in the Aegean Islands, perhaps Kition in Cyprus, that in Dead Sea Scrolls texts serves as a code word for “Romans” (Glossary)

Neil Silberman (1993)
“All these manuscripts, taken together, might be read as the recorded faith of a community of alienated, dispossessed Jewish priests and their followers who remained true to the strictest possible interpretation of the biblical laws.  They also remained true to the hope for national redemption from the yoke of the people they called the Kittim — and we call the Romans — idolatrous invaders from across the sea “who trample the earth with their horses and beasts.” (The Hidden Scrolls, p. 3)

NERO AS ENEMY / BELIAL
(UNDER CONSTRUCTION UNTIL MID 2019)

Barbara Levick
“The fourth ‘Sibylline Oracle’, composed by a Jew just after Vespasian’s death, encapsulates the grievances of Jews and Greeks, interpreting the eruption of Vesuvius as requital for the fate of Jerusalem, prophesying natural destruction and the return of Nero leading a Parthian army.” (Vespasian)

Jewish Sibylline Oracles (Written “Sometime after A.D.70”)
“Then Beliar will come from the Sebastinoi [i.e., the line of Augustus] and he will raise up the height of mountains, he will raise up the sea, the great fiery sun and shining moon, and he will raise up the dead. . . . But he will, indeed, also lead men astray, and he will lead astray many faithful, chosen Hebrews, and also other lawless men who have not yet listened to the word of God. (Sibylline Oracles 3:63-70; OTP 1:363.)

“One who has fifty as an initial will be commander, a terrible snake, breathing out grievous war, who one day will lay hands on his own family and slay them, and throw every-thing into confusion, athlete, charioteer, murderer, one who dares ten thousand things. He will also cut the mountain between two seas and defile it with gore. But even when he disappears he will be destructive. Then he will return declaring himself equal to God. But he will prove that he is not. Three princes after him will perish at each other’s hands.” (.5:28-35; OTP 1:393.)

“a savage-minded man, much-bloodied, raving nonsense, with a full host numerous as sand, to bring destruction on you.” (5:96; OTP 1:395.)

“a terrible and shameless prince whom all mortals and noble men despise. For he destroyed many men and laid hands on the womb. (5:143- 145; OTP 1:396.)

“There will come to pass in the last time about the waning of the moon a war which will throw the world into confusion and be deceptive in guile. A man who is a matricide will come from the ends of the earth in flight and devising penetrating schemes in his mind. He will destroy every land and conquer all and consider all things more wisely than all men. He will immediately seize the one because of whom he himself perished. He will destroy many men and great rulers, and he will set fire to all men as no one else ever did. Through zeal he will raise up those who were crouched in fear. There will come upon men a great war from the West. Blood will flow up to the band of deep-eddying rivers. Wrath will drip in the plains of Macedonia, an alliance to the people horn the West, but destruction for the king.” (Oracles 5:361-374; OTP 1:401-402.)

“making himself equal to God.” (12:79, 81, 86; OTP 14-47.)

ROME AS EDOM

“When Nero came to the Holy Land, he tried his fortune by belemnomancy thus:—He shot an arrow eastward, and it fell upon Jerusalem; he discharged his shafts towards the four points of the compass, and every time they fell upon Jerusalem. After this he met a Jewish boy, and said unto him, “Repeat to me the text thou hast learned to-day.” The boy repeated, “I will lay my vengeance upon Edom (i.e., Rome) by the hand of my people Israel” (Ezek. xxv. 14). Then said Nero, “The Holy One—blessed be He!—has determined to destroy His Temple and then avenge Himself on the agent by whom its ruin is wrought.” Thereupon Nero fled and became a Jewish proselyte, and Rabbi Meir is of his race. (Gittin, fol. 56, col. 1.)

ROME AND JUDAISM / ZAKKAI

Yochanan Ben Zakkai Sets up Yavneh
Gittin 56a describes how Yochanan ben Zakkai succeeded in establishing the court (beit din) at Yavneh despite the destruction of the Temple.

Gittin 56b:

Abba Sikra, the head of the biryoni (rebels, bandits, looters) in Jerusalem, was the son of the sister of Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai.

He (Yochanan) sent to him saying, Come to visit me privately. When he came he said to him: How long are you going to carry on in this way and kill all the people with starvation?”

He replied: What can I do? If I say a word to them, they will kill me.

He said: “Devise some plan for me to escape. Perhaps I shall be able to save a little.”

He said to him: “Pretend to be ill, and let everyone come to inquire about you. Bring something evil-smelling and put it by you so that they will say you are dead. Then let your disciples get under your bier, but no others, so that they shall not notice that you are still light, since they know that the living being is lighter than a corpse.”

He did so, and R. Eliezer went under the bier from one side and R. Joshua from the other. When they reached the gate, some men wanted to put a lance through the bier.

He said to them: Shall [the Romans] say, They [soldiers] have pierced their [the Jews’] Master?”

They wanted to give it a push. He said to them: “Shall they say that they pushed their Master?” They opened a town gate for him and he got out.

When he reached the Romans, he said: “Peace to you, O King. Peace to you, O King.”

He [Vespasian] said: “Your life is forfeit on two counts, one because I am not a king and you call me king, and again, if I am a king, why did you not come to me before now?”

He replied: “As for your saying that you are not a king, in truth you are a king, since if you were not a king Jerusalem would not be delivered into your hand, as it is written, ‘And Lebanon shall fall by a mighty one ‘[Isaiah 10:34]. “Mighty one” is applied only to a king, as it is written, And their mighty one shall be of themselves… [Jeremiah 30:21] and Lebanon refers to the Sanctuary, as it says, This goodly mountain and Lebanon [Deuteronomy 3:25]. As for your question, why if you are a king, I did not come to you until now, the answer is that the biryoni among us did not let me.”

He said to him: “If there is a jar of honey around which a serpent is wound, would they not break the jar to get rid of the serpent?”

He could give no answer.

R. Joseph, or as some say R. Akiba, applied to him the verse,’God turns wise men backward and makes their knowledge foolish [Isaiah 44:25].’ He ought to have said to him: We take a pair of tongs and grip the snake and kill it, and leave the jar intact.

At this point a messenger came to him from Rome saying: “Up for the Emperor is dead, and the notables of Rome have decided to make you king.”

He had just finished putting on one boot. When he tried to put on the other he could not. He tried to take off the first but it would not come off.

He said: What is the meaning of this?”

R. Yochanan said to him: “Do not worry: the good news has done it, as it says Good tidings make the bone fat [Proverbs 15:30]. What is the remedy? Let someone whom you dislike come and pass before you, as it is written ‘A broken spirit dries up the bones [Proverbs 17:22].’

He did so, and the boot went on.

He said to him: “Seeing that you are so wise, why did you not come to me until now?”

He said: “Have I not told you?”

He retorted, I too have told you.”

He [Vespasian] said: “I am now going and will send someone to take my place. You can, however, make a request of me and I will grant it.”

He said to him: “Give me Yavneh and its wise men, and the family chain of Rabban Gamaliel, and physicians to heal R. Tzaddok.”

R. Joseph, or some say R. Akiva, applied to him the verse, ‘[God] turns wise men backward and makes their knowledge foolish.’ He ought to have said to him: “Let them off this time.”

He, however, thought that he (Vespasian) [Vespasian] would not grant so much, and so even a little would not be saved… ” (Gittin 56b, Babylonian Talmud)

ON AION/OLAM

This two age/world schema is a thoroughly Jewish conception which the Christians picked up on.

Adam Clarke in his commentary frequently quotes Jewish thought in this regard The rabbis have a saying similar to this: “It is better for thee to be scorched with a little fire in this world than to be burned with a devouring fire in the world to come.”

“This money goeth for alms, that my sons may live, and that I may obtain the world to come. —Bab. Rosh. Hashshanah.

[Verily I say unto you, he shall in no wise lose his reward.] The rabbis have a similar saying: “He that gives food to one that studies in the law, God will bless him in this world, and give him a lot in the world to  come.” —Syn. Sohar.

This distinction of `owlaam (OT:5769) hazeh (OT:2088), this world, and of `owlaam (OT:5769) ha-ba’ (OT:935), the world to come, you may find almost in every page of the rabbis.

“The Lord recompense thee a good reward for this thy good work in this world, and let thy reward be perfected in the world to come. —Targum on Ruth.

“It (that is, the history of the creation and of the Bible) therefore begins with the Hebrew letter beth (b), in the word bªree’shiyt (OT:7225) because two worlds were created, this world and a world to come. —Baal Turim.

“The world to come hints two things especially (of which see Rambam, in Sanhed. cap. 2 Chelek.)
I. The times of the Messiah: `Be mindful of the day wherein thou camest out of Egypt, all the days of thy life: the wise men say, by the days of thy life is intimated this world: by all the days of thy life the days of the Messiah are superinduced.’ In this sense the apostle seems to speak, Heb 2:5, and 6:5.

1. The state after death: thus Rab. Tancum, The world to come, is when a man has departed out of this world.”

Therefore in the resurrection whose wife shall she be of the seven? for they all had her.  [Whose wife shall she be of the seven?] The rabbis have said, That if a woman have two husbands in this world, she shall have the first only restored to her in the world to come. —Sohar. Genes. fol. 24.

[Ye do err] Or, Ye are deceived-by your impure passions: not knowing the scriptures, which assert the resurrection:-nor the miraculous power of God (teen (NT:3588) dunamin (NT:1411) tou (NT:3588) Theou (NT:2316)) by which it is to be effected. In Avoda Sara, fol. 18, Sanhedrin, fol. 90, it is said: “These are
they which shall have no part in the world to come: Those who say, the Lord did not come from heaven; and those who say, the resurrection cannot be proved out of the law.”

Perhaps the Scriptures were never more diligently searched than at that very time: first, because they were in expectation of the immediate appearing of the Messiah; secondly, because they wished to find out allegories in them; (see Philo;) and, thirdly, because they found these scriptures to contain the promise
of an eternal life. He, said they, who studies daily in the law, is worthy to have a portion in the world to come, —Sohar. Genes. fol. 31.

From the tract Kiddushin, fol. 81.“Some captive women were brought to Nehardea, and disposed in the house and the upper room of Rabbi Amram. They took away the ladder (that the women might not get down, but stay there until they were ransomed.) As one of these captives passed by the window, the light of her great beauty shined into the house. Amram (captivated) set up the ladder; and when he was got to the middle of the steps (checked by his conscience) he stopped short, and with a loud voice cried out FIRE! FIRE! in the house of Amram! (This he did that, the neighhours flocking in, he might be obliged to desist from the evil affection which now prevailed in him.) The rabbis ran to him, and (seeing no fire) they said, Thou hast disgraced us. To which he replied: It is better that ye be disgraced in the house of Amram in this world, than that ye be disgraced by me in the world to come.

There is a saying among the rabbis very like that of the apostle in this and the preceding verse. Siphri, in Yalcut Simeoni, page 2, fol. 10: “The faces of the righteous shall be, in the world to come, like suns, moons, the heaven, stars, lightnings: and like the lilies and candlesticks of the temple.”

It is remarkable that the Jews themselves maintained that Abraham was saved by faith. Mehilta, in Yalcut Simeoni, page 1., fol. 69, makes this assertion: “It is evident that Abraham could not obtain an inheritance either in this world or in the world to come, but by faith.”

FIRE AND THE BURNT HOUSE

Psalm 66:12.  You humbled us, you made our creditors ride over our heads; you judged us as if by fire[115] and water, and you brought us out to a broad place. Another Targum: The Medes and Greeks rode over us, they passed over our heads; you brought us among the Romans, who judge us like the cruel Chaldeans, who cast our father Abraham into the fiery furnace, and the Egyptians, who cast our infants into the water; yet you brought us up to freedom.”

The Burnt House was found buried under a thick layer of destruction. Throughout the house, scattered in disarray among the collapsed walls, ceilings and the second story, were fragments of stone tables and many ceramic, stone and metal vessels, evidence of pillaging by the Roman soldiers. Leaning against a corner of one of the rooms was an iron spear, which apparently had belonged to one of the Jewish fighters who lived here. At the entrance to the side room, the arm bones of a young woman were found, the fingers clutching at the stone threshold. The many iron nails found in the ruins are all that was left of the wooden roof, the shelves and furnishings which were completely burnt. Numerous coins minted during the rebellion against the Romans (66-70 CE) attest to the date of the destruction of this house. In one of the rooms a round stone weight, 10 cm. in diameter, was found. On it, in square Aramaic script was the Hebrew inscription (of) Bar Kathros, indicating that it belonged to the son of a man named Kathros. The “House of Kathros” is known as that of a priestly family, which had abused its position in the Temple. A ditty preserved in talmudic literature speaks of the corruption of these priests:

Woe is me because of the House of Boethus,
woe is me because of their slaves.
Woe is me because of the House of Hanan,
woe is me because of their incantations.
Woe is me because of the House of Kathros,
woe is me because of their pens.
Woe is me because of the House of Ishmael, son of Phiabi,
woe is me because of their fists.
For they are the High Priests, and their sons are treasurers, and their sons-in law are trustees, and their servants beat the people with staves.  (Babylonian Talmud, Pesahim 57, 1 Tosefta, Minhot 13, 21)  

ON AQUILA

Translator of the canonical Scriptures from Hebrew into Greek. He was by birth a Gentile from Pontus, and is said by Epiphanius to have been a connection by marriage of the emperor Hadrian and to have been appointed by him about the year 128 to an office concerned with the rebuilding of Jerusalem as “Ælia Capitolina.” At some unknown age he joined the Christians, but afterward left them and became a proselyte to Judaism. According to Jerome he was a disciple of Rabbi Akiba. The Talmud states that he finished his translations under the influence of R. Akiba and that his other teachers were Eliezer ben Hyrcanus and Joshua ben Hananiah. It is certain, however, that Aquila’s translation had appeared before the publication of Irenæus’ “Adversus Hæreses”; i.e., before 177.

The work seems to have been entirely successful as regards the purpose for which it was intended (Jerome speaks of a second edition which embodied corrections by the author), and it was read by the Greek-speaking Jews even in the time of Justinian (Novella, 146). It was used intelligently and respectfully by great Christian scholars like Origen and Jerome, while controversialists of less merit and learning, such as the author of the “Dialogue of Timothy and Aquila” (published in 1898 by F. C. Conybeare), found it worth their while to accuse Aquila of anti-Christian bias, and to remind their Jewish adversaries of the superior antiquity of the Septuagint. But no manuscript until quite recently was known to have survived, and our acquaintance with the work came from the scattered fragments of Origen’s “Hexapla.” The reason of this is to be found in the Mohammedan conquests; the need of a Greek version for Jews disappeared when Greek ceased to be the lingua franca of Egypt and the Levant.

Fragments in the “Hexapla.”

The “Hexapla”—a colossal undertaking compiled by Origen (died about 254) with the object of correcting the text of the Septuagint—consisted of the Hebrew text of the Old Testament, the Hebrew text in Greek letters, the Septuagint itself as revised by Origen, and the Greek versions of Aquila, Symmachus, and Theodotion, all arranged in six parallel columns. With the exception of two recently discovered fragments of the Psalms, one coming from Milan, the other from Cairo,The Milan fragments, discovered by Dr. Mercati, are described by Ceriani in “Rendiconti del Real Istituto Lombardo di Scienze e Letteratura,” 1896, series ii., vol. xxix. The Cairo fragment (now at Cambridge) was edited by Charles Taylor in 1901. the “Hexapla” itself is no longer extant, but a considerable number of extracts, including many readings from Aquila, are preserved in the form of marginal notes to certain manuscripts of the Septuagint. These have been carefully collected and edited in Field’s great work (“Origenis Hexaplorum quæ Supersunt,” Oxford, 1875), which still remains the chief source of information about Aquila’s version.

Contrary to expectation, the readings of Aquila derived from the “Hexapla” can now be supplemented by fragmentary manuscripts of the translation itself. These were discovered in 1897, partly by F. C. Burkitt, among the mass of loose documents brought to Cambridge from the geniza of the Old Synagogue at Cairo through the enterprise of Dr. S. Schechter and Dr. C. Taylor, master of St. John’s College, Cambridge. Three of the six leaves already found came from a codex of Kings (i.e., they probably formed part of a codex of the Former Prophets), and three came from a codex of the Psalms. The portions preserved are I Kings xx 7-17; II Kings xxiii. 11-27 (edited by F. C. Burkitt, 1897); Ps. xc. 17, ciii. 17 with some breaks (edited by Taylor, 1900). The numbering is that of the Hebrew Bible, not the Greek. The fragments do not bear the name of the translator, but the style of Aquila is too peculiar to be mistaken. The handwriting is a Greek uncial of the sixth century. Dr. Schechter assigns the later Hebrew writing to the eleventh century. All six leaves are palimpsests, and in places are somewhat difficult to decipher.

The special value of the Cairo manuscripts is that they permit a more just conception of the general effect of Aquila’s version, where it agrees with the Septuagint as well as where it differs. It is now possible to study the rules of syntax followed by Aquila with far greater precision than before. At the same time the general result has been to confirm what the best authorities had already reported.

Literal Transmitter.

It would be a mistake to put down the harshness of Aquila’s translation to ignorance of Greek. He resorted to mere transliteration less than any other ancient translator, and had command of a large Greek vocabulary. Field (introduction, xxiii. et seq.) has collected a number of expressions that show Aquila’s acquaintance with Homer and Herodotus. It was no doubt from classical Greek literature that Aquila borrowed the use of the enclitic δε to express the toneless ה of locality. The depth of his Hebrew knowledge is more open to question, if judged by modern standards. But it is the special merit of Aquila’s renderings that they represent with great fidelity the state of Hebrew learning in his own day. “Aquila in a sense was not the sole and independent author of his version, its uncompromising literalism being the necessary outcome of his Jewish teacher’s system of exegesis” (C. Taylor, in Burkitt’s “Fragments of Aquila,” p. vi.).

Original Text of the Septuagint.

More important for modern scholars is the use made of Aquila’s version in Origen’s revision of the Septuagint. The literary sources of the Latin Vulgate are merely a point of Biblical archeology, but the recovery of the original text of the Septuagint is the great practical task which now lies before the textual critic of the Old Testament. Recent investigation has made it clear that Origen’s efforts to emend the Greek from the Hebrew were only too successful, and that every known text and recension of the Septuagint except the scanty fragments of the Old Latin have been influenced by the Hexaplar revision. One must learn how to detect Origen’s hand and to collect and restore the original readings, before the Septuagint is in a fit state to be critically used in emending the Hebrew. The discussion of this subject belongs rather to the criticism of the “Hexapla” than to a separate article on Aquila. It will suffice here to point out that Aquila’s version is one of the three sources by the aid of which the current texts of the Septuagint have been irregularly revised into conformity with a Hebrew text like that of our printed Bibles. For the association of the Targum of the Pentateuch with his name see Onkelos. nullSee also Bible.

Bibliography: Field, Origenis Hexaplorum quœ Supersunt, Oxford, 1875;
Wellhausen and Bleek, Einleitung in das Alte Testament, 4th ed., pp. 578-582, Berlin, 1878;
Burkitt, Fragments of the Books of Kings According to the Translation of Aquila, Cambridge, 1897;
Taylor, Origen’s Hexapla (part of Ps. xxii.), Cambridge, 1901;
S. Krauss, in the Steinschneider-Zeitschrift, 1896, pp. 148-163.
[See also Taylor’s Sayings of the Jewish Fathers, 2d ed., pp. viii. et seq.]T. F. C. B.

—In Rabbinical Literature:

“Aquila the Proselyte” and his work are familiar to the Talmudic-Midrashic literature. While “the Seventy” and their production are almost completely ignored by rabbinical sources, Aquila is a favorite personage in Jewish tradition and legend. As historical, the following may be considered. “Aquila the Proselyte translated the Torah (that is, the whole of Scripture; compare Blau, “Zur Einleitung in die Heilige Schrift,” pp. 16, 17) in the presence of R. Eliezer and R. Joshua, who praised him and said, in the words of Ps. xlv. 3 [A. V. 2], ‘Thou art fairer than the children of men: grace is poured into thy lips; therefore God hath blessed thee for ever.’” This contains a play upon the Hebrew word “Yafyafita” (Thou art fairer) and the common designation of Greek as “the language of Japhet” (Yer. Meg. i. 71c). In another place similar mention is made that Aquila announced his translation of the word in Lev. xix. 20 in the presence of R. Akiba (Yer. Ḳid. i. 59a). The parallel passage in the Babylonian Talmud to the first-cited passage (Meg. 3a) shows that by “translated in the presence of” is to be understood “under the guidance of”; consequently, Eliezer, Joshua, and Akiba must be regarded as the three authorities by whom Aquila governed himself. This agrees with what Jerome says (in his commentary on Isa. viii. 11); viz., that, according to Jewish tradition, Akiba was Aquila’s teacher—a statement which was also borne out by the fact that Aquila carefully rendered the particle every time by the Greek σύν, the hermeneutical system first closely carried out by Akiba, although not original with him (B. Ḳ. 41b). This would place Aquila’s period at about 100-130, when the three tannaim. in question flourished.

This accords with the date which Epiphanius (“De Ponderibus et Mensuris, ” chap. xiii-xvi.; ed. Migne, ii. 259-264) gives when he places the composition of Aquila’s translation in the twelfth year of Hadrian (129). A certain Aquila of Pontus is mentioned in a tannaite source (Sifra, Behar I. 1 [ed. Weiss, 106b; ed. Warsaw, 102a]). And, seeing that Irenæus (l.c. iii. 21) and Epiphanius (l.c.) agree that Aquila came from that place, it is quite probable that the reference is to the celebrated Aquila, although the usual epithet, “the Proselyte,” is missing. Aquila of Pontus is mentioned three times in the New Testament (Acts xviii. 2; Rom. xvi. 3; II Tim. iv. 19), which is only a mere coincidence, as the name “Aquila” was no doubt quite common among the Jews, and a haggadist bearing it is mentioned in Gen. R. i. 12. Zunz, however, identifies the latter with the Bible translator. Friedmann’s suggestion that in the Sifra passage a place in the Lebanon called “Pontus” is intended has been completely refuted by Rosenthal (“Monatsschrift,” xli. 93).

Relation to Onkelos.

A more difficult question to answer is the relationship of Aquila to the “proselyte Onkelos,” of whom the Babylonian Talmud and the Tosefta have much to relate. There is, of course, no doubt that these names have been repeatedly interchanged. The large majority of modern scholars consider the appellation “Targum of Onkelos,” as applied to the Targum of the Pentateuch, as a confusion (originating among the Babylonians) of the current Aramaic version (attributed by them to Onkelos) with the Greek one of Aquila. But it will not do simply to transfer everything that is narrated of Onkelos to Aquila, seeing that in the Tosefta (see index to Zuckermandel’s edition) mention is made of the relation of Onkelosto Gamaliel, who (if Gamaliel II. is meant) died shortly after the accession of Hadrian, while it is particularly with the relations between the pious proselyte and the emperor Hadrian that the Haggadah delights to deal. It is said that the emperor once asked the former to prove that the world depends, as the Jews maintain, upon spirit. In demonstration Aquila caused several camels to be brought and made them kneel and rise repeatedly before the emperor. He then had them choked, when, of course, they could not rise. “How can they rise?” the emperor asked. “They are choked.” “But they only need a little air, a little spirit,” was Aquila’s reply, proving that life is not material (Yer. Hag. ii. V. beginning 77a; Tan., Bereshit, ed. Vienna, 3b).

Concerning Aquila’s conversion to Judaism, legend has the following to say: Aquila was the son of Hadrian’s sister. Always strongly inclined to Judaism, he yet feared to embrace it openly in the emperor’s proximity. He, therefore, obtained permission from his uncle to undertake commercial journeys abroad, not so much for the sake of profit as in order to see men and countries, receiving from him the parting advice to invest in anything the value of which was temporarily depreciated, as in all probability it would rise again. Aquila went to Palestine, and devoted himself so strenuously to the study of the Torah that both R. Eliezer and R. Joshua noticed his worn appearance, and were surprised at the evident earnestness of the questions he put to them concerning Jewish law. On returning to Hadrian he confessed his zealous study of Israel’s Torah and his adoption of the faith, surprising the emperor, however, by stating that this step had been taken upon his, the emperor’s, advice. “For,” said he, “I have found nothing so deeply neglected and held in such depreciation as the Law and Israel; but both, no doubt, will rise again as Isaiah has predicted” (Isa. xlix. 7, “Kings shall see and arise, princes also shall worship”). Upon Hadrian’s inquiry why he embraced Judaism, Aquila replied that he desired very much to learn the Torah, and that he could not do this without entering the Abrahamic covenant: just as no soldier could draw his pay without bearing arms, no one could study the Torah thoroughly without obeying the Jewish laws (Tan., Mishpaṭim, V. ed. Buber, with a few variations, ii. 81, 82; Ex. R. xxx. 12). The last point of this legend is no doubt directed against Christianity, which acknowledges the Law, but refuses obedience to it, and is of all the more interest if taken in connection with Christian legends concerning Aquila. Epiphanius, for instance, relates that Aquila was by birth a Greek from Sinope in Pontus, and a relation (πενθερίδες) of Hadrian, who sent him, forty-seven years after the destruction of the Temple (that is 117, the year of Hadrian’s accession) to Jerusalem to superintend the rebuilding of that city under the name of “Ælia Capitolina,” where he became first a Christian and then a Jew (nullsee Aquila).

A reflection of the alleged adoption of Christianity by Aquila, as related by Epiphanius, may be discerned in the following legend of the Babylonian Talmud in reference to the proselyte Onkelos, nephew of Titus on his sister’s side. According to this, Onkelos called up the shade of his uncle, then that of the prophet Balaam, and asked their counsel as to whether he should become a Jew. The former advised against it, as the Jews had so many laws. and ceremonies; the latter, with characteristic spitefulness, replied in the words of Scripture, “Thou shalt not seek their peace nor their prosperity” (Deut. xxiii. 7 [A. V. 6]). He then conjured up the founder of the Church, who replied, “Seek theirpeace, seek not their harm; he who assails them touches the apple of God’s eye.” These words induced him to become a Jew (Giṭ. 56b, 57a). The founder of the Church (according to the Jewish legend) and the mother-church in Jerusalem (according to the Christian version) were the means of Aquila’s becoming a Jew.

The traces of the legend concerning Flavius Clemens, current alike among Jews and Christians, seem to have exerted some influence upon this Onkelos-Aquila tradition; but Lagarde goes so far as to explain Sinope in Pontus as being “Sinuessa in Pontia,” where Dimitilla, the wife of Flavius Clemens, lived in exile. Irenæus, who wrote before 177, states that Pontus was Aquila’s home. It is very questionable whether the account of Aquila in the Clementine writings (“Recognitiones,” vii. 32, 33)—an imperial prince who first embraced Judaism, and then, after all manner of vagaries, Christianity—was merely a Christian form of the Aquila legend, although Lagarde supports the assumption. The following Midrash deserves notice: Aquila is said to have asked R. Eliezer why, if circumcision were so important, it had not been included in the Ten Commandments (Pesiḳ. R. xxiii. 116b et seq.; Tan., Lek Leka, end; ed. Vienna, 20b, reads quite erroneously “Agrippa” in place of “Aquila”), a question frequently encountered in Christian polemic literature. That Aquila’s conversion to Judaism was a gradual one appears from the question he addressed to Rabbi Eliezer: “Is the whole reward of a proselyte to consist in receiving food and raiment?” (see Deut. x. 18). The latter angrily answered that what had been sufficient for the patriarch Jacob (Gen. xxviii. 20) should be sufficient for Aquila. When Aquila put the same question to Rabbi Joshua, the latter reassured him by expounding “food and raiment” as meaning metaphorically “Torah and ṭallit.” Had not Joshua been so gentle, the Midrash adds, Aquila would have forsaken Judaism (Eccl. R. to vii. 8; Gen. R. lxx. 5; Ex. R. xix. 4, abbreviated). The purport of this legend is to show that at the time Aquila had not been firmly convinced.

ON PAROUSIA DELAY

Question: What does “this generation” mean in the verse, “Truly I say to you this generation will not pass away until all these things take place” (Matthew 24:32, Mark 13:30, Luke 21:32)? 
Answer: Mark’s Jesus, after listing all the tribulations that the world must endure before he returns a second time (Mark 13:3-29, see also Matthew 24:3-33) exclaims: “Truly I say to you this generation will not pass away until all these things take place” (Mark 13:30, Matthew 24:34, Luke 21:32). Jesus was directing this remark specifically to his contemporary generation and not to some unknown future generation. Jesus, addressing his disciples “privately” (Mark 13:3, Matthew 24:3) listed what was going to happen before his return. He then added, “Then shall they deliver you up to be afflicted and shall kill you and you shall be hated of all nations for my names sake” (Matthew 24:9). Concerning this, Mark’s version adds, “he that shall endure to the end, the same shall be saved” (Mark 13:13). Thus, it appears from this last remark that at least some of the disciples would survive and be present to witness the second coming and the end of time.

According to Mark and Matthew, Jesus expected the tribulation period to occur before the last of his generation died out. Thus, a limit is given within which the prophecies are to be fulfilled. It should be noted that these “tribulations” were not fulfilled in the events of the years 66-73 C.E., the period of the First Jewish- Roman War. Jesus’ own statement shows that the culmination of the “tribulation period” was to see the parousia, the second coming of Jesus (Mark 13:26; Matthew 24:3, 30), which certainly did not occur during the war nor subsequently.

All of Jesus’ contemporaries died without seeing the fulfillment of his tribulation prophesy. As a result, Jesus’ words, especially the expression, “this generation” have undergone reinterpretation. Nevertheless, the translation of genea is “generation” or as Thayer explains it, giving Matthew 24:34 and Mark 13:30 as examples, “the whole multitude of men living at the time . . . used especially of the Jewish race living at one and the same period” (Joseph Henry Thayer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament, Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan Publishing House, 1979, p. 112). G. Abbott-Smith writes that the Greek word genea means “race, stock, family,” but in the New Testament always “generation” (G. Abbott-Smith, Manual Greek Lexicon of the New Testament, 2nd ed., Edinburgh: T.&T. Clarke, 1923, p. 89). Arndt and Gingrich note that the term means “literally, those descended from a common ancestor,” but “basically, the sum total of those born at the same time, expanded to include all those living at a given time, generation, contemporaries” (W.F. Arndt and F.W. Gingrich, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1957, p. 153).

There is no need to interpret the verse, “Truly I say to you this generation will not pass away until all these things take place” otherwise than that Jesus was speaking here of his contemporary generation. The expression “this generation” appears fourteen times in the Gospels and always applies to Jesus’ contemporaries. That generation passed away without Jesus returning. Therefore, we are confronted by another unfulfilled promise by Jesus. Jesus did not return during the period he himself specifically designated. Some commentators are of the opinion that “this generation” means the generation alive when this prophecy comes to pass, which they believe has yet to occur. However, the text shows that Jesus was not speaking to an unspecified future generation; he was speaking to his contemporary disciples and directed this prophecy to them personally.

Content Copyright Gerald Sigal, 1999-2003